Small Business Ordered to Pay Compensation Following Unfair Dismissal Over Fuel Allegations
A small Victorian earthmoving business has been ordered to pay more than $5,000 in compensation after the Fair Work Commission found that it unfairly dismissed a truck driver accused of stealing fuel.

In Wesley Ross Whitehead v S&K Whitehead Earthmoving [2026] FWC 4441, Commissioner Connolly found that although the employee had engaged in misconduct by taking fuel without confirming permission, his conduct did not justify immediate dismissal.
The decision highlights the importance of conducting a reasonable investigation and providing employees with procedural fairness, even where an employer suspects serious misconduct.
Background to the dismissal
Mr Whitehead had worked for S&K Whitehead Earthmoving since April 2022 and was regarded as a competent and hardworking employee.
In March 2026, the business owners received CCTV footage showing him filling his personal vehicle with fuel from the company’s depot in August 2025. The owners believed he had stolen fuel and decided his conduct warranted summary dismissal.
On 6 March 2026, Mrs Whitehead approached the employee and asked whether he had been stealing fuel. When he denied the allegation, she handed him a termination letter that had already been prepared.
The employee maintained that he believed he was permitted to use company fuel to reimburse himself for fuel consumed when using his personal vehicle for work purposes.
Small Business Fair Dismissal Code
The employer argued that the dismissal complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. Under the Code, a small business employer may dismiss an employee without notice where it believes on reasonable grounds that the employee’s conduct is sufficiently serious to justify immediate dismissal.
However, Commissioner Connolly of the Fair Work Commission emphasised that the employer’s belief must be supported by reasonable grounds, including a reasonable investigation. Although the business owners genuinely believed the employee had committed theft, the Commission found that their belief was not reasonably founded. The employer had no formal policy governing the use of company fuel or reimbursement for employees using personal vehicles.
Importantly, the Commission accepted that the employee genuinely believed he had permission to top up his vehicle, based on earlier discussions and workplace practices. The Commission also questioned the reliability of evidence provided by another worker following a workplace disagreement. Consequently, the employer had not complied with the Code.
Why the dismissal was unfair
The Commission separately considered whether the dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable under section 387 of the Fair Work Act 2009. Commissioner Connolly found that the employee should have confirmed permission before taking fuel and that his failure to do so constituted misconduct. However, the misconduct did not warrant summary dismissal.
The Commission was particularly critical of the employer’s decision to prepare the termination letter before speaking with the employee. Simply asking whether he had stolen fuel, without explaining the evidence or allowing him to respond properly, did not satisfy procedural fairness requirements. The dismissal was therefore found to be unfair.
Compensation awarded
The Commission assessed compensation on the basis that the employee’s employment would likely have continued for another five weeks, allowing for an investigation and termination with notice. The initial assessment of $8,487.50 was reduced by $3,395 to account for the employee’s own misconduct.
The employer was ordered to pay $5,092.50 gross, plus superannuation.
Lessons for employers
This decision reinforces that suspected theft does not automatically justify immediate dismissal. Before terminating employment, employers should ensure allegations are properly investigated, workplace policies are clear, and employees have a genuine opportunity to respond.
Small businesses may have fewer HR resources, but they must still establish reasonable grounds for summary dismissal. A rushed dismissal decision can expose an employer to an unfair dismissal claim, even where the employee has engaged in misconduct.
How Employer Services can help
Employer Services provides Australian employers with practical HR and workplace relations advice and support. Our subscription service includes access to experienced advisers, Modern Award information, employment templates, fact sheets and regular updates.

